When it comes to budget-friendly flooring, two options spring to mind – vinyl and laminate. But while they share some characteristics, they do have their differences, so how do you choose between them? In this blog we’ll do a deep dive into what sets these two flooring materials apart to help you make a decision for your own home.
At Greg Stone Flooring, we offer a great selection of different flooring options, including premium vinyl and laminate – why not visit us to browse our range in person?
What Sets Them Apart?
The main distinction between vinyl and laminate flooring is in their construction and core materials. Laminate flooring features a multi-layer design built around a high-density fibreboard (HDF) core. This wood-based foundation is topped with a photographic layer that creates realistic patterns, typically mimicking natural wood grain, and finished with a protective wear layer that provides scratch resistance and durability.
Vinyl comes in two forms – sheet vinyl and luxury vinyl tiles (LVT) or luxury vinyl planks (LVP), which are manufactured primarily from PVC. Its synthetic composition makes vinyl completely waterproof throughout its structure, unlike laminate which can be vulnerable to moisture damage at its core. The construction typically includes multiple layers as well, featuring a printed design layer sandwiched between protective coating and backing materials.
Which is More Durable?
Durability is one of the key factors that drive flooring decisions, and both of these materials excel in different scenarios. Since both have hardwearing protective surfaces, they’re far less likely to become damaged or scratched compared to hardwood floors, and they offer great resistance against fading from UV exposure, with laminate offering slightly better protection here, making it an ideal choice for rooms where there’s plenty of natural light.
Of course, neither is completely indestructible – vinyl can become dented from heavier furniture, while laminate can still become scratched although it can be repaired relatively easily with a colour-match repair kit.
Cost and Long-Term Value
Price points for both materials vary significantly based on quality levels and the brand. Entry-level laminate typically starts at more affordable price ranges, making them attractive for budget-conscious renovations or rental properties where you want to keep costs lower without compromising on quality. Premium laminate products with enhanced textures and realistic patterns command higher prices but still generally remain less expensive than luxury vinyl alternatives.
Luxury vinyl products can carry premium price tags, particularly those featuring advanced printing technologies and authentic textures. However, this initial investment can provide value in the form of superior performance in challenging environments and a potentially longer lifespan. As with any new floor, it’s important to balance the cost of installation with potential replacement timelines and maintenance requirements.
Get in touch for a quote or visit our warehouse
Room-Specific Recommendations
Different areas of your home present unique challenges that can influence your choice of flooring.
For kitchens and bathrooms, LVT’s waterproof properties provide obvious advantages – this material handles splashes, humidity, and temperature variations much more effectively, without compromising structural integrity. However, you still need to ensure there’s adequate ventilation in these spaces to prevent any potential issues with expansion and contraction and clean up major spills quickly to avoid damage.
Living areas, bedrooms, and dining rooms can benefit from laminate’s superior stability and fade resistance. The material’s harder surface provides excellent durability for furniture movement too.
While neither of these materials are as effective with underfloor heating as stone or ceramic tiles, they can both be used providing the temperatures don’t exceed 27oC to avoid any damage to your floors.
Maintenance
Both materials offer low-maintenance solutions compared to traditional hardwood or carpets, but their care requirements differ slightly. Laminate surfaces respond well to regular sweeping and occasional damp mopping with appropriate cleaners. It’s best to avoid excessive moisture during cleaning, as pooling water can potentially seep into seams and cause swelling or warping.
To clean vinyl floors, you can follow a similar routine cleaning but it will tolerate more aggressive approaches when necessary. The waterproof nature means occasional deeper cleaning poses no structural risks, but harsh chemicals and abrasive cleaning tools should still be avoided to preserve the surface finish and prevent premature wear.
Making Your Final Decision
Your choice between vinyl and laminate flooring ultimately depends on where it’s being installed, your budget and priorities, and long-term plans for the property. When choosing, think about factors like usage patterns in the room, how much moisture it will be exposed to, the overall look you’re striving for, and budget constraints. Vinyl is a preferable choice in wet environments and offers superior comfort underfoot, while laminate provides exceptional durability and authentic wood-like appearance in dry areas.
For further assistance in choosing the right flooring for your home, why not get in touch with us and we’d be happy to help. Alternatively, book a home visit and we can bring flooring samples to your home at a time that’s convenient to you.
